So my wife takes me to this new candy shop, Powell’s Sweet Shoppe. This place is awesome…all kinds of “old school” candy and they have a t.v. that plays Willy Wonka all day long. You can look around there forever and you don’t need to be a kid or take a kid to appreciate it. First thing I see though when I walk in is a refrigerator on the side wall with all kinds of colored and specialty drinks…so I said to myself, “Self…see if they have any specialty root beer.” You guessed it! My eyes focused in on that yellow-beeked bird on the bottle like the mother ship was calling me home! I swear the rest of the room went dark and the bottled glowed, while in the background you could hear the beginning of 2001 A Space Odyssey….dah…dah…dah…….dah-nah!
I grabbed 2 and went to the clerk, “How much, sir?” He said, “2 bucks a bottle.” I couldn’t get out my debit card fast enough. Then I said, “Wait, I gotta try it and make sure I want to buy more than 1.” Now I wasn’t thirsty and there was no way I was going to drink 16 ounces, but it was the moment of truth. One sip…and I bought 2.
After nursing that one down over the rest of the night and the next day, I thought to myself, do I really like it because it is better or because I want it to be? It’s hard to make this long story short…so let me sum up…I had to do a taste test.
So, Sunday night I went to the store to round up the usual suspects. Here were the participants, introduced by price/prestige:
- Big K (59cent 2/liter), less than $0.01/ounce
- Barqs, $0.02/ounce
- A&W and Mug, $0.023/ounce
- Thomas Kemper $0.063/ounce
- Henry Weinhard’s $0.064/ounce
- Sprecher $0.125/ounce
I tip my cap to the Mrs. for humoring me and setting up the taste test. Actually, I did stumble a bit out of the gate. As I started to take all the root beer out of the refrigerator and line up the glasses, my son asked me what I was doing. I immediately responded with a smile, “Mommy and Daddy are going to play a drinking game!” Now some things you don’t clearly think through when you say them…and my son loves games so I was only trying to make it fun for him too. Let’s just say as soon as the words had left my lips, I heard my wife from the other room, “Don’t tell him that! It’s a taste test!” I think we cleared that obstacle, but if you hear him say we played a “drinking game” when you are at church this Sunday…please give us the benefit of the doubt.
With that behind us, I gave each of the competitors an equal chance. I rinsed and chilled 7 small “drinking mugs” (I wised up and didn’t call them shot glasses) and placed them in the freezer for a couple minutes so each beverage would be welcomed into a frosty glass for maximum results. Here’s how it went down.
I sipped the first glass…pretty good I thought. The 2nd was very good as well (I was pretty sure it was the Henry’s). Although, after 2 that I liked I was thinking, “I’m a retard.” I was afraid I was going to like all of them and began to worry a bit. I have always thought Henry’s made a great root beer and the Sprecher I had a few days earlier was my new “pretty little pet.” Now I was going to prove myself a dingbat.
Then a sip of #3…my faith restored again…this one was terrible! #4…ok, but not near as good as 1 & 2. #5 about the same as #4. It was then I drank #6…as I sit here tonight writing this I still maintain that glass did not contain root beer! Terrible, does not do the name of the beverage justice. Finally #7…oh yeah…that’s a good root beer!
I then went back through the lineup one more time to confirm what I liked. Truthfully, I wanted to know what I did like the best and let the chips fall where they may. Yep, I still rank them #7 and #2 best followed by #1, then by #4 and #5, and #3 and #6 should be removed from all retail shelves immediately!
So what #’s were which ones? Here are my results from favorite to “not fit for human consumption”:
- Sprecher (oh, I still love my pretty little pet)
- Henry Weinhard’s
- A&W
- Mug
- Big K
- Thomas Kemper
- Barqs
Naturally, I then set up the test for my wife and here are her results:
- Henry Weinhard’s
- Mug
- Big K
- A&W
- Sprecher
- Thomas Kemper
- Barqs
I clearly love the Sprecher root beer. Obviously, my wife isn’t sophisticated enough to appreciate the full taste. That being said, Henry’s was a clear favorite and although the night before when we went out to pizza I had a Henry’s and my wife had a Barqs because she “likes it”…it is clearly an inferior root beer. For the record, our son liked A&W and Mug the best when he played the drinking game.
In my opinion, if you are down and out and need a shot of root beer, stop by Fred Meyer and get yourself a 59cent 2 liter bottle of Big K. For “every day” consumption A&W makes a good choice along with Mug. If you’re going to throw a Super Bowl party and want to get me something nice to drink, spring for a 6-pack of Henry’s. And if you forgot to buy me something for my birthday…stop by Powell’s and load me up with a Sprecher’s.
I’ve still got a lot of root beer in the fridge so feel free to stop by and join us for a drinking game some time!